Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am...

and I can remember.

Davies - 7 Made a couple of good saves one particularly in the 2nd half and looked assured on crosses. Maybe could have done better for the goal but was hamstrung by Yiadom not dealing with Ayew

Yiadom - 7 Would have been an 8 had he dealt with the goal better. He's turning in to a very good Championship full back. Got forward well throughout and worked his harris off.

Kepekawawaep. 5 - Not sure about him at left back. he looks like Nyatanga playing in the same position, like a centre half filling in. Looked knackered after 70 minutes. Good header for the goal though

Roberts - 7 First half he was iron, but as the game wore on he started to get exposed, not necessarily down to him though, as the rest of the back 4 started to shake.

MacDonald - 7 Looks a real find but has to stop the silly mistakes. I thought he was having his best game for us then gave it away in really silly position which should have resulted in a goal for Villa.

Hourihane - 6 Not his best game by a long shot. Still worked hard but started to look really leggy in the 2nd half. One occasion when Scowen pressed and we tried to push up as a team, hourihane was a mile behind and left a huge hole in midfield. Still dangerous from Set pieces though.

Morse - 6 Looked tidy in the first hour then lost his way and gave the ball away in increasing frequency, was rightly subbed.


Scowen - 8 Ran his blood to water and also was the only one to get in between the lines particularly in the first half. Should have shot in the 1st period instead of passing. Still a thorn in their side all night and was rightly given MOTM.

Kent - 7 Looked Dangerous but also lightweight at times. Needs to start though, gives us an outlet.

Watkins - 6 - Worked hard and looked tidy but didn't really stamp his authority going forwards

Bradshaw - 7 Gave his all and won his fair share up front on his todd. Hard role but I thought he applied himself well. Did his job well I thought.

Subs

Armstrong - 6 Looks lively without stretching them but they are quick and strong at the back

Winnall - 8 Looked as lively as he has done all season, good header to score and looked dangerous when he turned them around and ran at them

Hammier - 6 Surprised to see him benched but I understand why. Glimpses of his talent but also struggled to get into the game.

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Scowen had a shocker tonight he wasn't at it at all.

So many moves broke down through him.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Didn't he get motm? Raved about him on Barnsley player

Sent from my Kestrel using Tapatalk

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Opinions eh ? sounds like we watched different games

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Yeah got he got MOTM.

First half especially he was poor. Running around a lot but giving the ball away or taking the wrong option.

Roberts was MOTM in my opinion.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Interesting to hear such split opinions.

Sent from my Kestrel using Tapatalk

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

yes , agree with pretty much all of that

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Back to normal I don't agree with you mate. I thought Scowen did a good job, worked his socks and looked the main threat in the first half. But opinions are opinions and I respect yours, yer loony

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Agree with both those comments.

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

"Shocker" is a bit harsh.

But the bit I've quoted you on above is spot on.

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Worked his socks off yes. But lacked quality around the box to the point it stifled our game.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Re: Going to do one of those rating things because I wasn't pissed like I normally am

Marks look pretty spott on to me though Scowen would get 7 from me fantastic effort but he did seem to choose the wrong option quite a lot.

Morsy I would give 5 thought he did ok first half but was pretty poor second so 5 overall. Kpekawa I thought was poor all game and would get another 5 from me it would have been a 4 but his contribution to the gal. Rest seem spot on.